Congratulations! You have been elected chair of the board of a nonprofit you hold in high regard. Cue the applause! Strut to the front of the conference room while they play your walk-up music. And pay no attention to that tiny voice inside your head asking, what have I gotten myself into?

Becoming a nonprofit board chair is a bit like agreeing to adopt a lovable but high-maintenance puppy—you are excited, honored, and already slightly overwhelmed. You have attended many board meetings. You may have even chaired a committee or two. But now the gavel is yours. You are no longer just a member—you are its leader.

The Real Job Description (That No One Gave You)

Officially, you have been tasked with setting agendas, facilitating meetings, and working closely with the executive director. Unofficially, you are now the chief cheerleader, chief worrier, strategic thought leader, discussion facilitator, and occasionally, the peacemaker between colleagues. You find yourself fielding questions about finances, mediating passionate debates, and being asked to gently nudge those board members who have yet to make their annual gift, leaving money on the table and the organization short of the 100% board participation your major funder requires to receive their challenge grant award.

Your inbox and voice mailbox fills with updates about building repairs, fundraising shortfalls, and staff transitions. The issues often come in bunches, compounded by the last-minute text from your board development committee chair apologizing but can’t make the campaign pitch to your major prospect, scheduled for an hour from now. She wants to know if you can cover it.

Are you still reading? Good!

Because despite headaches and challenges, serving as the chair of a nonprofit board can be a joyful and rewarding experience.

The Power of the Chair

As board chair, you set the tone for board behavior. Your leadership influences whether the board is effective or unproductive, reactive, or strategic, whether it leads by directives and mandates, or brings a shared leadership perspective with the chief executive and management team.

You can ask tough questions while building consensus. You can move the board away from the rubber-stamping model of governance exemplified by low or erratic attendance (threatening quorums needed for necessary votes), listening to uninspiring reports, arguing over marginally significant issues – and instead move towards a more ambitious board model driven by a focus on casting a vision for the future of the organization and setting strategic direction. One where the board governs using consent agendas and effective use of committees in order to create space in board meetings for compelling storytelling, insightful data analysis and discussions of mission fulfillment and impact. And one where members actively engage in activities focused on financial health, growth, and sustainability.

Challenges? You Bet.

Let’s be honest: the issues facing today’s nonprofit boards are not for the faint of heart.

• Burnout and turnover are real—among staff and board members.
• Funding is competitive, and sustainability can feel like a moving target.
• Standing up for and with those who are marginalized and embracing different ideas and perspectives are still important, requiring empathy, humility, courage, and patience.
• Strategy, scenario planning, and adaptability are more crucial than ever in a post-pandemic, crypto, tariff, and AI-disrupted world.

And yet, these very challenges are what make your role as board chair so vital. You are not there to manage the nonprofit—that is the staff’s job. You are there to guide, support, and boldly ask what’s next?

So…Why Do It?

Because nonprofits shape our communities, educate and advocate for our children, care for the vulnerable and advocate for justice, feed the hungry, house the homeless, produce great art and culture, and protect our environment.

And because your leadership matters. Your voice and actions can ignite someone’s passion for the mission. You can make the difference between a board that simply meets and one that is ready to meet the moment.

A Call to Action for Board Leaders

To every new, aspiring, or reluctant board chair, know that your role is not just ceremonial—it can be transformational in big and small ways if you will accept the challenge. Lean into the mission. Listen. Be curious. Ask tough questions. Insist on excellence. Be generous with what you have to offer – time, money, influence, energy, etc. Be a cheerleader for the staff and volunteers. Be a thought partner, not just a supervisor, to your executive. And model behaviors you want to see in others.

Are you ready? The mission is counting on you!

‍

Bert is the Co-Founder and Principal of Armstrong McGuire. Learn more about Bert and check out his other musings in his bio.