Donor Retention and Communications

by
Shannon Williams
Start
End
Thursday, September 16, 2021

Donor Retention and Communications

Shannon Williams
Managing Partner

Donor retention is critical. You know it. You have heard the Armstrong McGuire team talk about it for years.

Unfortunately, donor retention rates are trending in the wrong direction according to the Fundraising Effectiveness Project (FEP) Fourth Quarter Report. The report states, “The overall 2020 donor retention rate was 43.6%, a 4.1% drop from the 2019 rate of 45.4%.” It is the lowest donor retention rate since FEP started tracking in 2007. Read more on this from the Association of Fundraising Professionals here.

The answer?

Timely communication about the impact of the gift is the key to donor retention. Penelope Burk, author of the industry-standard Donor-Centered Fundraising, repeated a well-researched mantra in her recent blog: “According to donors, It’s the information you send them before asking them to give again that makes them want to renew their support and, when it’s really satisfying, to give more generously.”

For a reminder of some of Penelope’s most important tips and a chance to submit some of your best examples of donor-centered communications, check out her blog: Communication is the Ask.

We all know it costs much less to retain a donor than to find a new one. Take a few minutes to read about the state of retention from the FEP and about how to improve retention from Penelope Burk using the links above. As you move full steam into fourth quarter fundraising, you will be glad you did.

Next>
Philanthropy Is Getting Closer to the Community
Next>
Making Room for the Aha! Moment
Next>
Measuring Performance
Next>
Can You Say No?
Next>
Become a Philanthropist
Next>
A Village of One
Next>
“You Can’t Be Good At Everything”
Next>
“Will” Power for the New Year
Next>
“So, Tell Me About Yourself”…How to Ensure You Move to the Next Step in the Interview Process
Next>
“55 Saves Lives”
Next>
“I’ve never been a natural, all I do is try, try, try.”
Next>
“Fun with Board and Org”
Next>
Who is Your Leprechaun?
Next>
Ziplining or Hang Gliding - What Fundraising Adventure Will You Choose?
Next>
You’ve Hired A New Employee Virtually (Or Are About To) – Now What?
Next>
You’re Invited!
Next>
Your Vibe Attracts Your Tribe
Next>
Your Path to Nonprofit Leadership Podcast Features AM Partner David Harris
Next>
Your Next Hire: A Strategic Investment
Next>
You Have A Strategic Plan. Now What?
Next>
You don't choose a life, you live one.
Next>
Writer’s Block: The Nonprofit Equivalent
Next>
Yes... and...
Next>
Yeah…If You Could Come To My Leadership Meeting, That’d Be Great.
Next>
Working From Home: A Lesson We Can't Unlearn
Next>
Winning the Lottery
Next>
Will our good fortune help or hurt the less fortunate?
Next>
Williams Named Managing Director of Armstrong McGuire
Next>
Why Sustainable Leadership Requires an Intentional Pause
Next>
Why Small Teams Work
Next>
Why I Need a Vacation
Next>
Who...are you…who, who, who, who…???
Next>
Who Did that Search?
Next>
Where's My Next Leader?
Next>
Where Do We Go From Here?
Next>
When you hit a hard spot.
Next>
Where are our Volunteers?
Next>
When the interim executive gig goes long…
Next>
When Stewardship Requires Sensitivity: Reflections on Aging Donors and Ethical Fundraising
Next>
When a Conversation Takes a Serious Turn
Next>
When Everything is Changing
Next>
What’s Your Why?
Next>
When Crisis Comes with the Territory
Next>
What's Your Giving Plan?
Next>
What Instrument Do You Play?
Next>
What you can control…
Next>
What nonprofits can learn from Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton
Next>
What is it About Pope Francis?
Next>
What is Your Organization’s Rating & Why Does It Matter?
Next>
What if Fundraising was an Olympic Sport?
Next>
What Nonprofit Leaders can Learn from a Brick
Next>
What Matters More - Donations or Donors?
Next>
What Makes a Successful Interim Executive? Lessons From My First Year Supporting Interim Leadership
Next>
What I Learned from a Box of Thank You Notes
Next>
What Is Needed Now
Next>
What Is A Campaign Cabinet (and Do I Need One?)
Next>
What I have learned over the past 6 years…
Next>
What Happens When You Fail
Next>
What Got Us Here Will Not Get Us There
Next>
What Good Is It If You Don’t Use It?
Next>
What Do the Olympics and Nonprofit Collaboration Have in Common?
Next>
What Comes Before Mission and Vision?
Next>
What Can We Learn From World Cup Fever?
Next>
We’re Number Three!
Next>
Wellness in the New Year
Next>
Welcome Senior Advisor Nicole Lindley to Armstrong McGuire
Next>
Welcome Karen Parker and Mickey Holt to Armstrong McGuire
Next>
Welcome to the Family!
Next>
Welcome Home: Amy Beros Joins the Food Bank of Central & Eastern North Carolina as President and CEO
Next>
Welcome
Next>
We have a lot to learn!
Next>
We Must Do More Than Talk About Racism
Next>
We Are Just Getting Started!
Next>
We Are A People Business
Next>
Wanna Play a Game?
Next>
Volunteer Appreciation
Next>
WANTED: Courageous Leaders with an Audacious Vision
Next>
Vegas, Inclusive Culture, and Ericka James
Next>
Value of Knowing Your Values
Next>
Values Based Leadership
Next>
UrbanPromise Charlotte: Rooted for Restoration
Next>
Urban Ministries of Wake County: The Transformative Powers of a Capital Campaign
Next>
Understanding Millennials
Next>
Unclutter Your Data
Next>
Unplugged Holiday
Next>
Uncharitable: Dispelling the Overhead Myth
Next>
Two Extremes
Next>
Two Ears, One Mouth
Next>
Two Ears and One Mouth
Next>
Twisters is Twister 2.0
Next>
Trust: Dollars Make the Greatest Impact in the Aftermath of Harvey
Next>
Trick or Retreat?
Next>
Trends In Funding Youth Education
Next>
Transitions
Next>
Top Ten Trick List for Fundraising Treats
Next>
Too Busy to Read? (Find the Time - It's Worth It)
Next>
To Give or Not to Give
Next>
To Be, Is To Be Perceived
Next>
Tips for Relaxing and Surviving Quarantine
Next>
Tips & Examples of Virtual Fundraising Events to Ensure Success
Read More from
Shannon Williams
Managing Partner
View Profile
What Do the Olympics and Nonprofit Collaboration Have in Common?
Thursday, February 26, 2026

I watched at least a few minutes of the Winter Olympics every day of the Games. I was continually struck by the resilience of the athletes—some who were competing as teams, but many who were competing as individuals.

Read the  Article
The Governance Perspective: Insights from Board Chairs
Thursday, January 15, 2026

Executive transitions are pivotal moments that can either stall momentum or unlock new opportunity.

Read the  Article
Armstrong McGuire and PMA Nonprofit Consulting Announce Merger to Strengthen Nonprofit Leadership Nationwide
Thursday, January 8, 2026

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: January 8, 2026 ‍- Armstrong McGuire and PMA Nonprofit Consulting Announce Merger to Strengthen Nonprofit Leadership Nationwide

Read the  Article
The Power of Scenario Thinking
Thursday, November 20, 2025

The Armstrong McGuire team has been honored to journey with several organizations in scenario thinking workshops and sessions in 2025.

Read the  Article
Fellowship in Focus: Monica Hopkins on Leadership, Learning, and Leaning Into Possibility
Thursday, November 20, 2025

At Armstrong McGuire, we believe that investing in leaders strengthens the entire nonprofit ecosystem.

Read the  Article
I AM

Staying Connected

Complete the form below to receive the latest updates, events, and insights.

*

indicates required

() -(###) ###-####
I AM

Ready to Partner

Curious about how we might work together or want to start a conversation? Share a few details using the form below.
Contact Us